Craig Spencer was more than just a wrestling coach—he was a mentor, a role model, and a pillar of strength for generations of young athletes. His coaching career began at Pequannock Township High School (PTHS) in 1975, where he led the wrestling program with unwavering commitment until 1988. During that time, he became the first coach in the school’s history to notch over 100 wins, compiling an impressive record of 113-55-5. Under his guidance, the team secured 5 Team District Championships and 3 League Championships, produced 28 Individual District Champions, and qualified 8 athletes for the State Tournament—an achievement that speaks volumes of his coaching acumen and ability to bring out the best in his athletes.
Coach Spencer’s legacy didn’t end at PTHS. He continued to shape the sport at Kean College from 1988 to 1995, followed by a successful tenure at Lakeland High School from 1995 to 2008. Even after stepping away from head coaching roles, his passion for the sport endured as he served as an assistant coach at West Milford High School from 2008 to the present day. His presence in the wrestling room, his voice in the corner of the mat, and his steady influence in the lives of countless student-athletes will be dearly missed.
Beyond the accolades and championships, Craig Spencer was a man of character, discipline, and compassion. He married his beloved wife Addie and together they shared 48 wonderful years. He was a devoted father to daughter Michelle and son Paul, and a loving grandfather to George and Logan. Family was his foundation, and the pride he took in his loved ones mirrored the pride he instilled in his athletes.
Tributes have poured in from former students, athletes, colleagues, and friends. One of his former wrestlers, Stephen Kass, poignantly shared:
“Coach Craig Spencer passed away today. He was an extraordinary man whose influence reached far and wide over the years. Those who knew him and had the privilege of wrestling for him are undoubtedly better people because of the lessons he instilled both on and off the mat. While my heart is heavy with sorrow, I’m filled with deep gratitude for having known him. He was one of the most influential figures in my life.”
Such sentiments reflect the profound impact Coach Spencer had not only on the wrestling mat but also in shaping the character and lives of those he mentored. His teachings extended far beyond wrestling holds and takedowns—he taught integrity, hard work, and perseverance.
On January 12, 2024, Craig Spencer was rightfully inducted into the Pequannock Wrestling Hall of Fame. This recognition now stands as a lasting tribute to a man who devoted his life to the sport and to the betterment of others.